The Devil is in the Details: A Cautionary Tale about Filing Builders Liens

Contributed by David Classen of Jenkins Marzban Logan LLP

The Builders Lien Act (the “Act”) provides powerful rights for unpaid contractors, subcontractors, and workers to file a claim of lien against the project land for the price of unpaid work and material. In exchange for these rights, the Act requires strict compliance with the prescribed manner, form, and time limits set out in the Act. Failure to comply with any of these requirements will be fatal to the lien claim.

The British Columbia Supreme Court recently emphasized the importance of strict compliance with the Act when filling out the form to file a lien in Omnique Construction Inc. v. Xu, 2017 BCSC 208.  

In this action, the defendant property owners had engaged the plaintiff, Omnique Construction Inc,. to provide forming and framing services. Following the termination of the contract, Ms. Sun, a director and officer of Omnique Construction Inc., attempted to file a builders lien. In filling out the builders lien form, Ms. Sun mistakenly named herself as the lien claimant instead of her company. She had correctly identified the amount owing and that the money was owed to the company and not to herself on the form, but had named herself as the lien claimant. The company subsequently commenced an action against the property owners to enforce the lien and filed a certificate of pending litigation (“CPL”) against the property.

The defendants applied for an order cancelling the claim of lien on the basis that the lien claimant was not identified correctly on the form. Omnique Construction Inc. and Ms. Sun opposed the order on the basis that the error was technical in nature and did not go the substance of the claim. They argued that the defendants were not misled or prejudiced in any way about the debt being claimed against them.  

The British Columbia Supreme Court rejected these arguments, relying on the well-settled law that there is a principle of strict compliance with the requirements of the Act regarding the time and manner in which the claim of lien is filed. The Court found that this principle was not fact-dependent and could not be relaxed to take into account the party’s intention when the claim of lien was filed. In accordance with the Act, the Court cancelled the lien, cancelled the company’s CPL and awarded costs and damages to the defendant property owners.

Omnique Construction v. Xu serves as an important reminder to lien claimants about the consequences of failing to carefully follow the requirements of the Act and, in particular, of incorrectly identifying the lien claimant on the lien form.

Although contractors, subcontractors, and workers are able to file a claim of lien without the assistance of a lawyer, seeking timely and appropriate legal advice can ensure that the strict requirements and timelines of the Act are met and that your lien rights are properly secured.  If you are inexperienced in filing builders liens or have any questions about the requirements of a lien claim, consulting with a lawyer can avoid making costly mistakes. If you do elect to file a claim of lien on your own, it is good practice to ensure you understand the legal distinction between incorporated and unincorporated entities and to consult your corporate records prior to filing a claim of lien to ensure you are naming the lien claimant correctly. 


This article first appeared in the Fall 2017 issue of SICA's Construction Review Magazine. To read the entire magazine click here.

2018-SICA-Chair-Dinner-125.jpg
September 13, 2018

8th Annual Chair Dinner & Awards Celebrates Industry Leaders

SICA held our annual Chair Dinner and Award Night where we celebrate member anniversaries, board volunteers, Gold Seal recipients, and scholarship recipients. In addition, this year we had the honor of awarding both a Consultant Award and the Innovation Award.
Read More
IMG_9870.JPG
June 28, 2018

2018 Kamloops Trap & Skeet

Every year the Kamloops Trap & Skeet is one of the most anticipated events we host! With over 100 attendees, BBQ steaks, and some tough competition it is safe to say that a blast was had by all.
Read More
IMG_9545.JPG
June 27, 2018

2018 SICA Golf Tournament

On June 21st, 2018 144 golfers converged on Sunset Ranch Golf Course for the annual SICA Golf Tournament. Despite lightening in the valley causing a brief course closure and pouring down rain in the afternoon the event was a huge success!
Read More
IMG_9202.JPG
May 30, 2018

2nd Annual Family Fishing Derby

The beautiful Roche Lake Resort was again the site for our now 2nd annual Family Fishing Derby. This event, hosted through a joint partnership between the Southern Interior Construction Association and CapriCMW Insurance, is quickly becoming a must attend for all SICA members.
Read More
Terry-Brown-CCA-Award-1.jpg
April 30, 2018

Celebrating our Own - Terry Brown Receives CCA's Person of the Year Award

The CCA Person of the Year Award recognizes individuals who demonstrate the qualities of a leader and who apply the highest standards and principles of the construction industry and business community. To those who have had the opportunity of working alongside Terry Brown, he is the living embodiment of this description.
Read More
Heavy-Metal-Rocks-2018.JPG
April 24, 2018

10th Anniversary of Heavy Metal Rocks in Kamloops

2018 marked the 10th year of the Heavy Metal Rocks event in Kamloops. This project provides opportunities for Grade 11 and 12 students from the School District No. 73 to explore career opportunities in the heavy equipment operator field.
Read More
Kelowna-Construction-Breakfast-8.jpg
April 19, 2018

Construction Industry Celebrates BC Construction Month at Okanagan College

The Kelowna building community was proud to celebrate BC’s Construction & Skilled Trades Month with a breakfast held at Okanagan College on Thursday. In the newly built Trades Building contractors, apprentices, foundation program students and industry support organizations gathered to recognize the impact the construction industry has on the BC and specifically the Okanagan economy.
Read More
Brandon_TKI.png
March 07, 2018

Member Spotlight: TKI Construction

TKI recently completed construction on the flagship Mr. Lube store in Kelowna, where they went beyond your standard oil change facility and built a truly stunning building. Brandon had the opportunity to work with the Mr. Lube franchise owner to design a tower and architectural details that make the store more visually appealing than it would otherwise be.
Read More
BCCA Employee Benefits logo.JPG
February 07, 2018

Unsung Benefits

The BCCA Employee Benefits’ plans offer other services beyond dental and extended health care.
Read More
iStock-619508318.jpg
January 24, 2018

Message Delivered, Message Received

Successful buildings have always been the result of collaboration between the client, designers, and contractors. A strong team, clear expectations, and concise information will typically result in a project which all involved parties will consider successful. Through recent decades the delivery of projects has changed with increased complexity, decreased timeframes, and changing delivery methods. Now more than ever it is critical that the collaboration between the team occurs to ensure the desired outcome.
Read More
img-bdo.png
December 20, 2017

TAX ALERT – Government Simplifies Measures to Rein in Income Sprinkling

On December 13, the federal government released legislation to simplify restrictions on income sprinkling, proposed to go into effect January 1, 2018. These revisions indicate they’ve listened to feedback during the consultation period, by providing more certainty to taxpayers through the introduction of “bright-line” tests to automatically exclude some family members, and allow income sprinkling for those members who make sufficient contributions to the business.
Read More
8F - 2006 Mack Dump Truck.jpg
December 13, 2017

Member Spotlight: Ok Excavating

Adaptability, initiative, and customer service are the keys to longevity for a local commercial and residential excavation business in Kelowna. OK Excavating is celebrating 50 years of business in 2017 and, in those years, has undergone many evolutions.
Read More
cyber-security-2851201_1920.jpg
November 29, 2017

Construction and Cyber Risk: An Overview

A hazard such as a fire has protocols and procedures that are designed to mitigate risks – inspections, suppression systems, and risk management practices. Cyber protection of a business should also employ a rigorous process to develop both a risk prevention and incident response plan. Most cyber insurance applications serve as a catalyst in moving towards this process.
Read More
calculator-1044173_1280.jpg
November 15, 2017

Could Tax Issues Throw Your Business Off Track?

To stay on track, real estate and construction companies should develop a better understanding of where tax issues are likely to complicate or disrupt their business — and develop a plan to mitigate those risks well in advance.
Read More
father-2090061_1920.jpg
November 08, 2017

Top Five Reasons for Having an Employee Benefits Plan

One of the biggest investments employers can make is in their employees. And it makes sense to want productive, healthy, and engaged employees. Employees with poor health cannot exert the effort required to be highly productive, and you need engaged employees in order to create innovative solutions.
Read More
courthouse-1799353_640.jpg
August 30, 2017

Obligation of Good Faith in Contracting

The Supreme Court of Canada changed the legal landscape for contracts in the decision of Bhasin v. Hrynew, [2014] SCC 71. This decision created a new common law obligation of good faith that applies to all commercial contracts.
Read More
write-593333_1920.jpg
August 23, 2017

Embracing the Purpose Era

Regardless of the size of your business or the sector you operate in, the purpose movement is shaking up the rules of business and ringing in a new era where business is an active participant in making the world a better place.
Read More
blueprints-1837238_1920.jpg
April 05, 2017

Reaching the Millennials | Attracting the right people is in how the story is told

With businesses adjusting to the era of the happy workplace, concepts such as social responsibility, company culture, and employee engagement are common buzz words used around the open-concept, flexible, shared workspace. They are used more so as companies shift their recruiting focus toward the millennials, the largest generation in the workforce today.
Read More